Our Menu
Appetizers
Sticks with Cheese
Thin pizza crust with garlic butter and the best mozzarella cheese around. Served with warm homemade from-scratch pizza sauce on the side | Sm $6.50 | Lg $9.00
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Our soft, homemade Italian bread, is coated with garlic butter and piled high with mozzarella cheese. Served with warm pizza sauce on the side | Half order (5pc) $6.50 | Full order (10pc) $10.00
Oven Roasted Wings
Straight from Buffalo, New York! World-famous La Nova wings served with celery sticks and Parmesan dressing. Our wings are oven-baked, which takes a bit longer
Hot Wings
World-famous La Nova wings and drummies tossed in a secret hot sauce and oven-baked. Served with celery sticks and bleu cheese dressing. Our wings are oven-baked, which takes a bit longer | 1/2 lbs. $7.50 | 1 lbs. $13.00 | 1/2 lbs. of each kind: $13.00
Holy Meat Balls
$7.00
Two homemade meat balls with Marinara Sauce and 2 pieces of grilled garlic bread
Soup of the Day
Cup $3.50 | Bowl $5.00
Homemade Chili
Cup $4.50 | Bowl $6.00
HOMEMADE SAUCES AND DRESSINGS
Alfredo Sauce 8oz
$2.50
Pizza or Spaghetti Sauce
Small (4oz) $1.50 | Large (8oz) $2.00
Homemade Dressings
House Parmesan, Ranch, French, Thousand Island, Italian, Blue Cheese & Light French | 8oz $3.00 | 12oz $4.00
Burritos & Chili
Burrito
$10.00
A Minnesota-style burrito with savory burrito seasoned beef, fresh tomatoes, cheddar cheese, and sour cream wrapped in a tortilla and served on a bed of lettuce, topped with salsa and sour cream. This burrito weighs nearly a pound! Uffda!
Chili Burrito
$11.00
Our regular burrito, covered with chili, cheese and a side of sour cream
Chili Spaghetti
$9.50
Whoa! What a great combination! Our tangy homemade chili served over thin spaghetti noodles then topped with cheddar cheese. Served with grilled garlic bread
Calzones
Our calzones use fresh ingredients and are folded into our ciabatta-style dough and then baked to a golden brown…You’ll dream of these in your sleep! Please allow a few extra minutes for our calzones - they’re worth the wait!
Pizza Calzone
$11.00
Any three pizza toppings, mozzarella cheese, and our homemade pizza sauce
Smedly Calzone
$12.00
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green and black olives, extra cheese, pizza sauce
Taco Supreme Calzone
Taco meat, onions, black olives, tomatoes, sour cream, and taco sauce. Topped with crushed taco shells, lettuce, and cheese. Extra taco sauce and sour cream served on the side | Beef $12.00 | Chicken $12.50
Chicken Cordon Bleu Calzone
$12.50
Grilled chicken breast, ham, mushrooms, cheese, and homemade Alfredo sauce, folded into an unforgettable calzone
Vegetarian Calzone
$11.50
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, green/ black olives, tomatoes, cheese, pizza sauce
Italian Beef Calzone
$12.50
Tender roast beef, onions, green peppers, Italian seasonings, and delicious mozzarella, folded into one of our famous calzones. Served with our pizza sauce and Parmesan dressing on the side
Stromboli
Stromboli is an Italian wrap sandwich, starting with our homemade pizza crust, wrapped around fresh ingredients, then brushed with garlic butter and special seasonings and baked in the oven | The Stromboli is served with chips or substitute a cup of soup or chili for $2.50
Philly Stromboli
$11.50
Roast beef, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella cheese. Served with Parmesan dressing
Mama’s Stromboli
$11.50
Ham, turkey, pepperoni, salami, tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese
Turkey Bacon Stromboli
$11.50
Turkey, bacon and mozzarella cheese, served with ranch dressing
3-Topping Stromboli
$11.50
Choice of 3 sub toppings and mozzarella cheese, then wrapped into a Stromboli
Hot Meatball Stromboli
$11.50
Same as our Hot Meatball sub below only in an Italian wrap not on bread
Hot & Cold Sub Sandwiches
HOT SUBS
Served with chips. Substitute a cup of soup or chili for $2.50
Hot Meatball Sub
$11.50
Our homemade meatballs served on grilled Italian bread, topped with onions, our spaghetti sauce, and melted Italian cheeses
Hot Mama’s Sub
$11.50
Pepperoni, salami, ham, turkey, tomatoes, cheese, and Italian dressing, oven-baked and served on grilled Italian bread, then dressed with mayonnaise and lettuce. Your new favorite sub
Hot Italian Beef Sub
$11.50
A pile of roast beef, onions, green peppers, Italian seasonings, and melted mozzarella cheese, baked and served with our homemade parmesan dressing
Gyros
$10.00
Tender slices of Gyros strips thinly sliced and grilled; garnished with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Served with tzatziki sauce (a classic Greek cucumber sauce) on warmed pita bread
COLD SUBS
Served on our homemade Italian bread with chips. Substitute a cup of soup or chili for $2.50 | Cold subs are not available heated
Two Meat Sub
Your choice of two meats and any other vegetable toppings, dressed with garlic butter, tomatoes, cheese, lettuce, mayonnaise, and Italian dressing on our homemade Italian bread | Half $7.00 | Full $10.00
Three Meat Sub
Your choice of three meats and any other vegetable toppings, dressed with garlic butter, tomatoes, cheese, lettuce, mayonnaise, and Italian dressing on our homemade Italian bread | Half $7.50 | Full $10.50
Mama’s Sub
Pepperoni, salami, ham, turkey, tomatoes, lettuce, cheese, mayonnaise, garlic butter, any other vegetable toppings, and Italian dressing on our homemade bread | Half $8.00 | Full $11.50
Toppings
Pepperoni, Salami, Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Lettuce, Cheese, Tomatoes, Onions, Pickles, Green Olives, Black Olives, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, and Jalapeno Peppers
Just for Kids
For 10 & Under -- $6.50 -- Meals include a single serving of applesauce a drink, and a treat | Kids menu is for dine-in customers only | Sign up for the birthday club and get a FREE pizza on your next birthday
Happy Face Pizza
$6.50
8-inch pizza that’s sure to make you smile
Single Topping Pizza
$6.50
8-inch pizza with child’s choice of 1 topping
Macaroni and Cheese
$6.50
A childhood favorite! Served with potato chips
Corn Dog
$6.50
Make any day feel like the State Fair! Served with potato chips
Spaghetti
$6.50
Thin noodles topped with spaghetti sauce, served with a piece of garlic bread
Papa's Pies
Our own famous creation! You won’t find anything else like it. Ingredients are piled between two made-from-scratch pizza crusts, baked, and brushed with butter. Please allow a few extra minutes - they’re worth the wait!
Spaghetti Pie
$11.00
Thin spaghetti noodles, our own rich spaghetti sauce, and mozzarella cheese | Add Two Meatballs for $3
Alfredo Pie
$11.50
Sausage, mushrooms, thin spaghetti noodles, made-from-scratch Alfredo sauce, and cheese | Substitute chicken or shrimp for an additional $2.50
Taco Supreme Pie
Taco meat, onions, black olives, tomatoes, sour cream, and taco sauce. Topped with crushed taco shells, lettuce, and cheese. Taco sauce and sour cream served on the side | Beef $11.50 | Chicken $12.00
Dinner Entrees
All entrees are served with 2 pieces of grilled garlic bread and your choice of soup or a house-side salad | Half orders do not include soup or salad and are served with one piece of garlic bread | Add Chicken or Shrimp for only an additional $3
Manicotti
$13.50
Tube-shaped pasta filled with our creamy ricotta cheese blend, baked with our homemade spaghetti sauce and mozzarella cheese
Spaghetti with Homemade Sauce
Half order $7 - of thin spaghetti topped with our fantastic sauce, served with one piece of garlic bread | Full order $11 - of thin spaghetti noodles topped with loads of our hearty spaghetti sauce | Add one of our homemade meatballs for an additional $1.50
Homemade Lasagna
Half order $7 - of lasagna: served with one piece of garlic bread | Full order $14.50 - A mountain of layers of our rich, hearty spaghetti sauce, ricotta cheese blend, sliced meatballs, tender lasagna noodles and secret spices. We promise that you’ll crave it
Papa’s Combo
$15.00
Half servings of spaghetti & a meatball and our fabulous lasagna. The best of both worlds
Papa’s Pasta
$14.50
A fantastic blend of creamy white sauce loaded with an assortment of cheeses, ham, bacon, mushrooms, and tomatoes, with penne noodles delicately tossed in. Wow, this is amazing
Chicken Carbonara
$14.00
Homemade Alfredo sauce, diced tomatoes, fresh mushrooms, bacon, and artichoke hearts, tossed in seasoned grilled chicken and spaghetti noodles
Fettuccini Alfredo
$12.50
Fettuccini noodles and mushrooms delicately tossed in our creamy Alfredo sauce
Tortellini
$12.50
Tender, cheese-filled tortellini served with either our homemade spaghetti or Alfredo sauces
Baked Penne
$14.00
Penne noodles topped with spaghetti sauce, layered with sliced meatballs, baked with mozzarella cheese
Bianco Baked Penne
$14.00
Penne noodles topped with our signature white sauce, layered with chicken and mushrooms, baked with mozzarella cheese
Pasta Primavera
$13.00
Sautéed onions and green peppers, diced tomatoes, fresh mushrooms, artichoke hearts, fresh broccoli, tossed gently with our creamy Alfredo sauce and thin spaghetti noodles (Made spicy upon request!)
Cowboy Pasta
Penne Noodles, Onion, Bacon, Chicken, Alfredo and BBQ sauce mixed together covered with mixed cheese and baked
Pizza
At Papa's, we make our pizzas from scratch, using the finest and freshest flours, homemade sauce, premium cheeses, fresh meats, and crisp produce | Order your pizza with Papa’s new lingo
“On Fire”
Ask the kitchen to add crushed hot peppers before baking
“With Love”
Add Papa’s extra special blend of Italian spices before baking
Pick from Our Homemade Crusts
Regular Hand Tossed • Chicago Style Pan • Super Thin • Crispy St. Louis Style | Just add an additional $1.00 for St. Louis style
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
No substitutions of ingredients on specialty pizzas, please!
Smedly's
Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green olives, black olives, and extra cheese | Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $11, 12" $17.50, 14" $22 | Chicago Pan - 10" $17.50, 14" $23 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $14.50, 16" $18
Zimmerman Special
Sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and extra cheese | Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $11, 12" $17.50, 14" $22 | Chicago Pan - 10" $17.50, 14" $23 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $14.50, 16" $18
St. Francis Special
Sausage, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, hamburger, salami, crispy bacon, and extra cheese | Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $12, 12" $18, 14" $23 | Chicago Pan - 10" $18, 14" $24 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $15.50, 16" $18.50
Papa's Favorite
Sausage, Canadian bacon, extra sauce, and extra cheese | Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $10.50, 12" $16.50, 14" $20 | Chicago Pan - 10" $16.50, 14" $21 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $13.50, 16" $16.50
Mama's Favorite
Sausage, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, green and black olives, pineapple, cheese | Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $12, 12" $18, 14" $23 | Chicago Pan - 10" $18, 14" $24 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $15.50, 16" $18.50
Taco (Chicken or Beef)
Chicken or beef taco meat, onions, tomatoes, black olives, topped with crushed taco shells, lettuce, and cheese. Taco sauce and sour cream served on the side. (Jalapenos on request) | Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $12, 12" $18, 14" $23 | Chicago Pan - 10" $18, 14" $24 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $15.50, 16" $18.50
Cheeseburger
Hamburger, crispy bacon, onions, pickles, tomatoes, cheddar, and mozzarella cheese | Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $11, 12" $17.50, 14" $23 | Chicago Pan - 10" $17.50, 14" $24 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $14.50, 16" $18
Vegetarian
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, green olives, black olives, tomatoes, and cheese | Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $11, 12" $17.50, 14" $22 | Chicago Pan - 10" $17.50, 14" $23 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $14.50, 16" $18
CREATE YOUR OWN PIZZA
Cheese
Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $7, 12" $11, 14" $15 | Chicago Pan - 10" $11, 14" $16 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $10, 16" $13
Toppings (ea)
Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $1.30, 12" $1.80, 14" $2.30 | Chicago Pan - 10" $1.80, 14" $2.30 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $1.80, 16" $2.30
Extra Sauce
Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $0.80, 12" $0.90, 14" $1.00 | Chicago Pan - 10" $0.90, 14" $1.00 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $0.90, 16" $1.00
Substitute Alfredo Sauce
Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $1.20, 12" $1.70, 14" $2.20 | Chicago Pan - 10" $1.70, 14" $2.20 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $1.70, 16" $2.20
Chicken or Shrimp
Regular Hand Tossed - 8" $1.90, 12" $2.90, 14" $3.70 | Chicago Pan - 10" $2.90, 14" $3.70 | Take-N-Bake - 12" $2.90, 16" $3.70
Pick Your Toppings
Pepperoni, Sausage, Extra Hot Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Hamburger, Salami, Crispy Bacon, Mushrooms, Banana Peppers, Pineapple, Green Olives, Black Olives, Artichokes, Dill Pickles, Green Peppers, Sauerkraut, Jalapeno Peppers, Broccoli, Tomatoes
Salads
Top them with one of Papa’s fresh, tasty, homemade dressings - House Parmesan, Ranch, French, Thousand Island, Italian, Bleu Cheese, Light French | Extra dressings $0.50 each
Papa’s Chef Salad
$11.00
A combination of crisp mixed greens, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, mushrooms, tomatoes, green and black olives, onions, and green peppers, topped with homemade garlic croutons and Italian cheeses. Served with two slices of our grilled garlic bread
Mama’s Chef Salad
$11.00
Our Papa’s Chef Salad with a lower fat version for Mama! Substitute turkey for the other meats. Served with 2 slices of grilled garlic bread
Hawaiian Chicken Salad
$11.50
Mixed crisp salad greens, pineapple, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, green and black olives, tomatoes, a warm grilled garlic chicken breast cut into bite-size pieces, topped with garlic croutons and Italian cheeses. Served with two slices of soft, grilled garlic bread
Taco Salad
Crisp lettuce, taco meat, tomatoes, green and black olives, green peppers, onions and cheese. Served with tortilla chips and accompanied by taco sauce and sour cream on the side | Beef $11 | Chicken $11.50
Gyros Salad
$11.00
Greek-style salad, including mixed crisp greens with fresh tomatoes, red onions, black olives, feta cheese, and homemade garlic croutons, topped with grilled gyros strips. Dressed with a special cucumber tzatziki sauce on the side
House Side Salad
Crisp mixed greens, fresh tomatoes, black olives, homemade croutons, and Italian cheeses | Small $4.50 | Large $7
Desserts
Try a rich dessert that's made just for you
Tiramisu
Tiramisu is a rich, layered Italian dessert that's made with coffee-soaked ladyfingers and whipped egg, sugar, and mascarpone cream | $ Ask when ordering
Daily Lunch Specials
Daily lunch specials served 11 am to 3 pm
Mama Mia
$8.00
Includes a cup of "soup of the day" or a cup of chili. Plus, Salad includes crisp lettuce, black olives, tomatoes, cheese, and croutons. With your choice of one of our homemade dressings. Plus, includes a Mama Mia Melt - ham and turkey with Italian seasoning. Served on an open-faced Italian bread topped with cheese and baked to perfection
Spaghetti
$8.00
Full order of spaghetti and two pieces of garlic bread
Mini Mama's Chef
$8.00
Combination of mixed greens, turkey, mushrooms, tomatoes, black and green olives, onions, green peppers, topped with homemade garlic croutons, and Italian cheeses. Served with one slice of grilled garlic bread
Serving Zimmerman and surrounding area - We cater events within 30 miles of Zimmerman - Try our catering for your next event - Call 24 hours ahead for catering
Menu
Entrees
Small pan serves 8-10 People, and comes with 20 pieces of garlic bread | Large pan serves 18-20 People, and comes with 40 pieces of garlic bread | Baked Spaghetti, Baked Penne, Papa’s Pasta, Chicken Alfredo, Manicotti | Small pan $45, Large pan $80 — Lasagna - Small pan $55, Large pan $90
Homemade Sub Sandwiches
Mama’s sub 4 meats (Ham, Turkey, Salami, Pepperoni) | 2 Meat sub, you choose what 2 | Small pan (serves 5), Large pan (serves 10) | Small 2Meat $17 - Mama’s $20 | Large 2Meat $32 - Mama’s $38
Stromboli’s
Stromboli is a baked Italian wrap sandwich, we start with our homemade pizza crust and mozzarella cheese, wrapped around your choice of up to 3 toppings | Small pan (serves 6 people) $35 | Large pan (serves 12 people) $60
Salad
Mixed greens, black olives, carrots, croutons, Italian cheese with our homemade Ranch and French dressings on the side | Small serves 10-12 people $15 | Large serves 20-24 people $30
Desserts
Dessert Platter (brownies and cookies) | Serves 10 - $16